Senedd ministers wanted to pay illegal immigrants £1,600 a month.
To many, this claim will seem so outlandish that they will assume it isn’t true.
But alarmingly, it is. And warped policy priorities like this explain why public services in Wales are failing.
Senedd ministers wanted to make the payments through their Universal Basic Income pilot, which has now come to an end.
In 2023, in a letter to the then-British Government, they stated, “in line with the Welsh Government’s Nation of Sanctuary approach … we ensure that asylum seekers are not prevented from accessing appropriate Welsh Government schemes and benefits.”
They went on to say that should they 'meet the basic eligibility criteria of the pilot, they have the right to enrol and participate.'
But Senedd ministers were concerned that the payments could take recipients over the eligibility threshold for legal aid to fight deportation.
Warning that 'each individual recipient may be at different stages of the asylum process,' they asked the British Government to discount the payments when assessing legal aid eligibility.
They also asked that they be 'excluded from any legal aid exemptions.'
The British Government rightly refused.
But Senedd ministers’ actions will horrify most Vale residents.
Most reasonable, moderate people can see that our asylum system is abused.
Many people are in our country with no legal right to be here.
Asylum claims are routinely refused. By making the £1,600 payments available on the basis which they did, Senedd ministers ensured illegal immigrants were eligible.
And rather than assist British Government efforts to remove people in our country illegally, Senedd ministers’ actions constituted an attempt to make it easier for them to stay.
To make my position clear, I opposed the Universal Basic Income pilot from the outset.
It was a bad policy and I called it out at the time.
Now it has come to an end, the public need to understand its effects.
In the Senedd last week, I raised this with the social justice minister.
I requested that a breakdown of the scheme’s effectiveness be published prior to the end of the current Senedd term.
But I was told the evaluation is 'at mid-point' and 'will continue into 2027.'
This is not good enough.
Immigration and asylum are not devolved to the Senedd. But health is. 1-in-4 people are on an NHS waiting list in Wales.
When Senedd ministers prioritise ideological vanity projects, they divert time, money and resources away from what matters.
The Universal Basic Income pilot was supported by both Plaid Cymru separatists and Labour.
Vale residents deserve to know the truth about it before they vote in the next Senedd election next May.
Andrew RT Davies is member of the Senedd for South Wales Central.
Share